The Man thinks I am evil as I only bought one antler at the pet store this week. The reason is, if there are two, they only ever chew one, and they still have half an antler they are chewing. Also, they do a pretty good job sharing.
They did such a good job when the new one, they did something rare, they shared the bed. Hailey wasn't thrilled that Phod joined her but tolerated it!